The national wealth of our country, the heritage of all south africans, shall be restored to the people. The purchase of shares nationalisation is a financial transaction, except if this is operated by mean of confiscation this is another flow. Debate on nationalising the mines in south africa south africa. What implications would nationalization have on the global mining economy as a whole. Privatisation is so ideologically loaded a word in south africa that mere mention is enough to provoke protest, so we use euphemisms like restructuring. The economic freedom fighters eff aims to pick up where the anc government has failed its people. How privatisation versus nationalisation debate is on a fast track to nowhere people want more than what is on offer with the now stale, mostly elitist and selfconstructed choice between. It is of little surprise south africas economically disenfranchised ethnic majority are talking of nationalisation and land reform fri 30 jul 2010 06. The current bourgeois economic machinery needs to be dismantled in order to ensure true economic emancipation of the majority of south africans.
This paper considers the case for nationalizing the local mining sector from. Nationalisation in the reasons to nationalise south. What has been the record of nationalised industries. Alternative needed to nationalisation and privatisation. Nationalisation of mineral rights in south africa saflii. Sam kongwa, researcher at the africa institute, presented this paper on southern.
It cohen professor of international law and human rights. By mid1986 an estimated 34 foreign companies had quit south africa, most of them selling out to south african monopolies. South africa braces for economic fallout of land nationalisation move the push for a change in the legislation has sparked a fierce debate in the top industrialised african economy wheat fields. What objectives has national isation sought in other countries and how are these reflected in south. Nationalisation is high on the policy agenda in south africa. The nationalisation of the bank will require an amendment to the south african reserve bank act which stipulates the private shareholding. Nationalization refers to the process of a government taking control of a company or industry, which generally occurs without compensation for the loss of the net worth of seized assets and. In addition, nationalisation leads to the government playing a more active role in distribution as private enterprises do not always consider the welfare of the countrys inhabitants. Ancyl nationalisation document pdf in a discussion document titled programme of action for economic freedom in the issue of the nationalisation of the mines was raised by the ancyl and it. Nationalisation of the sarb would thus align the banks ownership structure with the majority of central banks across the world. Many key industries nationalised were natural monopolies. The corollary is that nationalisation would give the government, as the major shareholder, control over central bank policy.
The nationalisation of mines in south africa is a costly, highrisk proposition that should be adopted only as a last resort, an independent panel of experts is reported to have concluded after a. A similar structure was introduced in south africa. The opposites of nationalization are privatization and. Given that the shares do not pay out quality dividends, malikane said the objective of prospective shareholders is to have access to state reserves, such as gold. Unpacking the implications of nationalising the reserve. Other than in south africa, central banks with private shareholders can be found in seven other countries. Pdf nationalization is high on the policy agenda in south africa. The new debate around commodity cycles is, will south africa participate in the next wave. This paper considers the case for nationalizing the local mining sector from an evidencebased perspective, which is derived from theoretical considerations and related to the known features of the south african mining sector and economy. Back to a prosperous future, or down a rabbit hole. The state, privatisation and the public sector in south africa. Nationalisation in the reasons to nationalise south africa.
Even though south africas reserve bank has private shareholders, they have absolutely no say over monetary policy. Nationalisation, socialisation and the freedom charter. Nationalisation would create panic among foreign investors. South africa blue sky publications pty ltd ta thesouthafrican number. See the zabalaza pamphlet fighting privatisation in south africa and south africa. The mining sector, after nationalisation, could take a very long time to boast a profit. Nationalization usually refers to private assets or assets owned by lower levels of government, such as municipalities, being transferred to the state.
Nationalisation of the mines in south africa economics essay. Nationalization is high on the policy agenda in south africa. Nationalisation in south africa a debate that will. South africas ruling party has taken a decision to nationalise the south african reserve bank and it will be implemented, president cyril ramaphosa has said. Constitution a bailout is a form of nationalization in which the government takes temporary control of a majority of a company and its assets. Keywords nationalization, south africa, mining sector. Nationalization doesnt have to cut out the private sector completely.
How south africa hosts the world cup will go a long way in defining and redefining the perceptions and misperceptions people in the world have about. Chidambaram, to have helped the indian economy withstand the global financial crisis of 20072009 1949 1 january reserve bank of india nationalised. Privatisation is the fundamental policy of the anc and it will be implemented. This is because fixed costs are so high in creating a network of water pipes, there is no sense in having any competition.
The programme of nationalisation represents a shift in the economic policy of south africa as currently proposed by the eff. The black private elite in south africa, these measures are closely tied to the ancs historic agenda of fostering a prosperous noneuropean bourgeois class. How privatisation versus nationalisation debate is on a. Questions to be asked about nationalisation in south africa if there is going to be nationalisation of the south african mining industry, there will need to be a very full and explicit spelling. Africa is seminal and is a vital addition to the growing critical literature on south africas transi tion from apartheid. Currently south africa is one of the most unequal societies in the world and nationalisation will bridge the gap between rich and poor. It is not entirely stateowned, but the state still has a huge stake in it about 39%. The proposal to nationalise the south african mining industry has provoked heated and often. Nationalisation in south africa will benefit the majority of south africans. This paper considers the case for nationalising the local mining sector from an. Advantages and disadvantages of nationalisation may 19, 2017 may 17, 2017 by editor in chief nationalism is one of the fastest rising trends in the world, but overall, there has been stiff resistance to this movement, but regardless there is good and bad regarding nationalisation. From nationalisation to privatisation in south africa nationalisation of the mines, banks and monopoly industries is the policy of the anc and a change or modification of our views in this regard is inconceivable.
The anc has taken a decision to nationalise the south african reserve bank and it will be implemented, president cyril ramaphosa has said. Amendments require a simple majority in parliament. If nationalization is the only way to lift the majority of the countrys people out of poverty and deprivation, then south africa had better commit substantially more resources to producing mining professionals. Nationalisation, socialisation and the freedom charter robert davies ihe freedom charter adopted by the congress of the people on 26 june 1955 includes the following wellknown and much discussed clause. Africas experience of nationalization, at the national african federated. By 1986 a noticeable decline in copper production resulted in the closure of many mining units and led to the implementation of a fiveyear plan to revive the company8. Nationalisation would align the south african reserve banks ownership structure with the majority of central banks across the world. It must be bank of south africa so that we radically depart from the past.
These are belgium, greece, italy, japan, san marino, switzerland and turkey. Appropriate compensation for the nationalization of existing private businesses is mandated by the charter of economic rights and duties of states, adopted by the united nations general assembly in 1974, as well as by the fifth amendment of the u. The nationalisation in zambia was to also increase government revenue that was supposed to lead to increased social spending. In fact, i will add that the south african reserve banks name must be changed. The reserve bank of india was stateowned at the time of indian independence 1953 air india under the air corporations act 1953. A storm erupted in policy circles in south africa after julius malema the leader of the african national congress youth league ancyl boldly proclaimed the need for the mining industry in south africa to be nationalized. Nationalization, or nationalisation, is the process of transforming private assets into public assets by bringing them under the public ownership of a national government or state. The privitisation of the electricity industry in south africa. As such, it helps one see how globalisation and the major trends in the. Most of the uks major strategic heavy industries and public utilities were nationalised between 1946 and the early 1950s, only to be returned to the private sector between 1979 and 1990 examples of nationalisation.
While threats of nationalisation loom large, reserve bank. South africa has a history of state owned enterprises that havent been very successful, this would place more doubt in the mind of the foreign invertor. Privatisation is inevitable in sa but you may not r. Is the nationalisation of the south african mining industry a good. There is a common set of justifications for nationalisation and some countries would legitimately cite these and others have been. This means the most efficient number of firms in the industry is one. Internationally, however, this approach has changed since the 1930s. Nationalisation can be encouraged by both economic need and political agendas.
Nationalisation of central banks during the period of economic hardship in the midst of the great depression commenced with the nationalisation of the central banks of new zealand in 1935 and denmark in 1936. The difference between nationalisation and privatisation the advantages and. Ah, telkom, holder of the fixed line, telecommunication monopoly of south africa. Recent calls by the african national congress anc youth league to nationalize south africas mining industry have resurrected a seemingly neverending debate. Advantages and disadvantages of nationalising mines. Advantages and disadvantages of nationalisation connectus. Regus business centre 1st floor, block b, north park, black river park, 2 fir street. The impact of the proposed nationalisation of south african mines on employment in the platinum sector ii abstract many forums have been recently organised in south africa to discuss the level of state intervention in the minerals sector, the expropriation of private mining companies, and the transfer of mineral wealth to the people. South africas former african national congress youth league leader, julius malema, has.
In the case of norway and bolivia nationalisation was to regain control of natural resources that would provide the necessary revenue to fund much needed development. The nationalised banks were credited by many, including former finance minister p. Nationalising south african mines stellenbosch university. The impact of the proposed nationalisation of south. We have got to go through processes, ramaphosa told parliament in cape town on thursday. The demand was predicated on fulfilling the vision of the freedom charter, which was adopted at kliptown in 1955 as the manifesto of the liberation struggle. Nationalisation of mineral rights in south africa 129 and must be sanctioned for a public purpose or in the public interest. I was rather intrigued by news reports that gwede mantashe, secretary general of the anc, has hinted that.
1030 102 1301 1373 849 996 307 386 517 1083 1275 807 826 500 332 1330 727 528 950 143 666 1549 1507 802 76 992 920 553 166 202 1284 1265 123